RHONY, Season 16, Episide 11–Peeling Back the Layers

Welcome back to Jurassic Snark, where the New York Housewives are once again roaming their natural habitat: expensive restaurants, emotionally hazardous birthday parties, and conversations that begin with friendship and end with somebody questioning somebody else’s entire existence.

This week on The Real Housewives of New York City, Jessel celebrates her birthday with a Bollywood-themed party, Daisy continues her campaign to alienate every woman within a five-mile radius, Erika brings a gift that should probably come with a warning label, and Carole Radziwill discovers that the best way to settle a disagreement is apparently to publish an essay about it. Meanwhile, Lindsay Hubbard arrives from the Summer House ecosystem, gets thoroughly lubricated, and reminds us that sometimes the most useful person at a Housewives party is the one who can barely stand upright.

Let’s get into the prehistoric mess.

We begin with Daisy, who is still upset with Sai and would very much like the entire group to understand that she is the injured party. At lunch with Carole, Erin, and Hailey, Daisy explains that she wants Sai to behave more like a friend. Apparently, this means Sai should chase after her whenever she storms off, provide emotional support on demand, and intuitively understand what Daisy needs without Daisy having to communicate any of it.

Hailey offers an inconvenient counterexample. When she became upset at Daisy’s seder, Sai actually went after her, comforted her, and persuaded her to return. Hailey remembers this as evidence that Sai can be a good friend. Daisy seems to remember it as a personal betrayal because, for some reason, she would also like Sai to chase her down the street.

There is a difference between wanting a friend to show up for you and wanting a friend to demonstrate loyalty through a series of increasingly elaborate emotional obstacle courses. Daisy appears to be requesting the latter.

But instead of staying focused on her own friendship with Sai, Daisy suddenly turns her attention toward Hailey.

Daisy announces that people have questions about Hailey, that her stories don’t add up, that nobody really knows her, and that there are apparently concerns about where her money comes from. Hailey asks for specifics, and Daisy delivers the financial question. Hailey explains that her parents help support her. No kidding. I don’t understand why this was ever a mystery or why anyone ever cared about it.

The problem isn’t necessarily that people have questions. The problem is the way Daisy delivers them. She isn’t having a private conversation with Hailey to understand her circumstances. She’s using Hailey’s personal life as ammunition in an argument about Sai. Daisy is awful.

Daisy then announces that Sai has also questioned Hailey, effectively trying to drag Sai into the confrontation. Erin remains relatively quiet, prompting Daisy to point out that Erin isn’t saying anything and that Daisy is now being made to look like the asshole.

Daisy, a helpful observation: sometimes people look like the asshole because of what they are actually doing.

Hailey has had enough. She tells Daisy that she’s done with her, and it’s difficult to blame her. There is something particularly unpleasant about being told that an entire group of people is discussing your personal life while the person delivering the news is simultaneously pretending to be your friend.

Later, Hailey meets her mother for lunch, and we get a more personal look at what is happening beneath the designer clothes and the increasingly confusing explanations.

Hailey talks about her marriage to Reuben and admits that she sometimes feels more like his caretaker than his wife. She’s been with him since she was 22, and the idea of a life without him is difficult to imagine.

Then comes the conversation about her relationships with women and her mother’s past disapproval. Hailey explains that her mother had expressed the belief that women who were together were that way because they couldn’t get men. Hailey connects that history to her decision to be with Reuben.

It’s a revealing conversation, and it raises questions about how much of Hailey’s adult life has been shaped by expectations placed on her when she was younger. She seems to be trying to understand what she actually wants, separate from what other people have wanted for her.

We don’t get a neat conclusion, and perhaps that’s the point. Hailey is still figuring things out. Her marriage, her identity, and her relationship with her mother are complicated subjects that don’t magically resolve themselves over lunch.

But at least we’re getting something more interesting than another round of Daisy’s financial investigation.

Jessel’s birthday party arrives, and the Bollywood theme gives us a lovely setting for what will inevitably become another Housewives battlefield. Jessel looks to be enjoying herself, and Pavit delivers a speech that is, shall we say, not destined for the Hall of Fame of romantic birthday tributes.

There are also some awkward husband moments, including Pavit’s reluctance to take pictures with his wife and his apparent willingness to eat food off the floor. Romance is alive and well in the Randhawa household.

Hailey is wearing Jessel’s wedding dress, which is a lovely detail and a much better use of a wedding dress than most of the things happening at this party.

But the real surprise guest is Lindsay Hubbard, who arrives looking spectacular and proceeds to become increasingly, gloriously drunk.

Lindsay is operating at a level of enthusiasm that suggests she has mistaken this birthday party for a job interview, a social experiment, and possibly a personal appearance tour. She and Carole hit it off immediately, and the two become the party’s unofficial commentary department.

Lindsay is also perfectly willing to say what everyone else is thinking, which brings us to the evening’s most memorable present.

Erika gives Daisy a bottle of memory supplements.

Yes. Memory supplements.

This is not a subtle gesture. This is not a thoughtful little birthday present. This is a pharmaceutical middle finger wrapped in a gift bag.

The joke refers to their previous disagreement, in which Erika suggested Daisy’s memory might be questionable. Erika has apparently decided that the best way to repair their relationship is to purchase a product that suggests Daisy’s brain needs maintenance.

Lindsay immediately recognizes the gift for what it is: a fuck-you present.

And honestly, thank you, Lindsay. Sometimes a Housewives party needs somebody willing to translate the social subtext for the rest of the room.

Erika believes Daisy treats her like a courtesy friend rather than a genuine one. She also seems to think Daisy wants to be the Martha Stewart of the group, collecting allies and managing the social environment.

I don’t necessarily think Daisy is trying to become Martha Stewart. I think Daisy is trying to become the person everyone likes, and she’s having a difficult time understanding that constantly criticizing people and dragging them into arguments is not an especially effective strategy.

Erika’s gift is funny, but recycling an old joke isn’t exactly a revolutionary comedy concept. Still, it gives Lindsay something to work with, and Lindsay is more than happy to carry the bone from one side of the party to the other.

She and Carole discuss the situation, laugh hysterically, and appear to be having considerably more fun than several of the actual Housewives.

Meanwhile, Daisy’s friendship problems are multiplying like dinosaurs in an uncontrolled breeding experiment.

Hailey is talking with Daisy’s sister, Samona, when Daisy approaches. Hailey makes it clear that she isn’t interested in engaging with her. The body language is unmistakable. The friendship has entered its extinction phase.

Eventually, the women find themselves in a larger conversation involving Sai and Jessel. Hailey is animated, using her hands while explaining what happened at lunch. Daisy tells her to calm down with her hands, which is particularly interesting considering Daisy had been gesturing at Hailey during their earlier confrontation.

Daisy again insists that everyone was talking about Hailey and that Sai was among those questioning her. Then she turns to Sai, essentially asking her to confirm the accusation.

Unfortunately for Daisy, Sai has a memory that appears to be functioning without supplemental assistance.

Sai explains that she had already asked Hailey the questions directly during their shopping trip. She had told Hailey that certain things weren’t adding up. She wasn’t pretending otherwise, and Hailey knew exactly where Sai stood.

That is a rather important distinction.

Sai may have questioned Hailey, but she did so directly. Daisy, on the other hand, used the alleged opinions of the entire group as a weapon during an argument and then tried to make Sai validate the whole performance.

Daisy wanted Sai to become a co-conspirator in a conversation Sai wasn’t actually having.

The difference between being direct and being messy is apparently something Daisy is still studying.

At this point, Daisy seems to want everyone to agree that she is the honest one, the loyal one, and the one who has been wronged. Unfortunately, her methods keep producing the opposite result. She is so busy trying to make other people look bad that she doesn’t notice how thoroughly she’s undermining herself.

And now we arrive at the other major feud of the evening: Sai versus Carole.

Remember Carole’s Substack essay about an onion and the unpleasant experience of peeling back its layers? Well, the essay was clearly connected to her issues with Sai, even if Sai wasn’t named.

The underlying conflict goes back to Sai questioning Carole about the Epstein files and Carole’s past connections. Carole was uncomfortable with the way Sai approached the subject, believing that Sai was treating her as though she had already done something wrong.

Carole has a legitimate point that there is a difference between asking questions and conducting an interrogation. But writing an entire essay about an onion as a metaphor for a castmate is a fairly elaborate way of saying someone got on your nerves.

Sai discovers the essay and isn’t exactly thrilled. She brings it up and asks Carole whether she actually wrote it herself or whether ChatGPT helped.

Oh, no. Not another AI writing scandal.

Carole, who has spent years establishing herself as the intellectual of the Housewives universe, is not about to let that accusation pass without a response. She turns the tables and starts examining Sai’s own Substack writing, suggesting that a substantial portion of it appears to have been generated by artificial intelligence.

Suddenly, we’re no longer watching a Housewives disagreement. We’re watching two women conduct a forensic examination of each other’s writing samples.

Somewhere, an English professor is preparing a plagiarism rubric.

Carole’s argument is that Sai was aggressive and accusatory when questioning her about Epstein, while Sai’s position is that Carole is hiding behind literary metaphors and public essays instead of addressing the issue directly.

Both women have a point, and both women are making sure nobody forgets it.

Carole has always had a talent for delivering a cutting observation with a perfectly composed expression. But Sai is not intimidated, and she seems perfectly willing to challenge Carole in front of everyone.

The onion has been peeled. The Substacks have been inspected. The robots have been summoned.

What a time to be alive.

This episode belongs to Daisy’s increasingly complicated social experiment, with Lindsay Hubbard arriving as the unexpected party MVP and Carole and Sai turning a friendship dispute into a literary crime scene.

Daisy’s biggest problem is that she seems to want the benefits of being everyone’s friend without accepting the responsibilities that come with it. She wants people to chase her, reassure her, validate her, and take her side. When they don’t, she starts explaining what everybody else supposedly thinks about everybody else.

That’s not friendship. That’s a group project in which Daisy has appointed herself the professor, assigned everyone else’s roles, and become furious when they don’t follow the syllabus.

Hailey, meanwhile, is giving us glimpses of a much more complicated personal story. Her conversation with her mother was one of the more revealing moments of the episode, and I hope we get to see her explore those questions without the entire cast turning her life into a group investigation.

Sai and Carole are nowhere near finished with each other, and the Substack situation has the potential to become one of those Housewives feuds that produces an entire reunion segment devoted to reading receipts aloud.

And Lindsay? Please invite her back. She arrived, got drunk, identified a passive-aggressive gift, carried gossip, and made friends with Carole. That’s a productive evening by any measure.

Jessel got her birthday party. Daisy got memory supplements. Sai got an essay written about her. Carole got accused of using ChatGPT. Hailey got a complicated conversation with her mother. And Lindsay got a very successful night out.

The dinosaurs have spoken: the ecosystem is unstable, the friendships are endangered, and nobody should be allowed near a Substack without adult supervision.

Until next time, keep your claws sharp, your receipts organized, and your memory supplements handy. You never know when Erika might send you some.

Comments

Leave a Reply