
I am home sick. Again. And watching old-school RHONY on Peacock. I just had to recap this classic.
There are vacations, there are girls’ trips, and then there is the St. Barth’s expedition, which will eventually become a cautionary tale about tequila, questionable decision-making, and the dangers of allowing a French-speaking man in a pirate costume anywhere near a woman who has recently been photographed wearing a Countess title.
But before we get to the pirate, we must first address the departure of the ladies of New York for their Caribbean adventure. And, naturally, one member of the group is already missing.
Aviva Drescher, whose relationship with air travel can best be described as an ongoing hostage negotiation, has decided that she cannot make the journey. Her fear of flying is apparently sufficiently powerful that even the prospect of spending several days in a luxurious St. Barth’s villa cannot overcome it. For most people, a tropical vacation is an incentive to get on the plane. For Aviva, it is apparently an incentive to remain firmly attached to the ground.
And so the women depart without her, leaving the rest of the cast to enjoy the island without having to accommodate Aviva’s increasingly complicated relationship with basic transportation.
The ladies arrive at their beautiful villa, which is exactly the sort of accommodation one would expect when a group of wealthy New York women decides that a regular hotel simply will not do. There are gorgeous views, luxurious surroundings, and enough space for everyone to have a private meltdown without disturbing the other guests.
This is not a camping trip. Nobody is going to be sharing a bathroom with strangers or worrying about whether there are enough towels. These women have arrived in paradise, and they intend to experience every square inch of it while wearing expensive swimwear.
Carole’s boyfriend Russ is also on the island for a blues festival, and he conveniently arrives to join the group. Carole is clearly happy to have him there, and his presence provides a welcome change of scenery from the usual revolving door of female grievances.
Russ is a musician, which immediately gives him a certain advantage in this environment. He has an actual reason to be on the island beyond participating in a televised argument about who said what at a charity event.
The women settle in, and eventually the evening’s entertainment takes them to Le Ti, a popular St. Barth’s nightclub where the evening’s festivities include tequila, dancing, and a pirate-themed performance.
Now, one might reasonably expect a pirate-themed nightclub performance to involve some costumes, perhaps a little theatrical swordplay, and a few people pretending to be on a ship.
What one might not anticipate is that it will become the central romantic mystery of an entire season of television.
Enter Tomas Ribeiro.
Tomas is a French-speaking Johnny Depp look-alike who appears in pirate attire and immediately attracts the attention of LuAnn de Lesseps. He is not merely a man in a costume. He is an EVENT. He has the hair, the swagger, the accent, and the general appearance of someone who has wandered off the set of Pirates of the Caribbean and accidentally found himself in a Bravo production.
LuAnn notices him.
And when LuAnn notices a man, the atmosphere changes.
Here is a woman who has spent years cultivating an image of elegance, sophistication, and aristocratic restraint. She has a title, a cabaret career, a collection of statement necklaces, and a romantic relationship with Jacques. She is also apparently not immune to the charms of a man wearing a pirate hat.
Sonja and the other women observe the developing situation with considerable interest. Sonja, in particular, recognizes that something entertaining may be unfolding. The Countess has spotted a pirate, and the pirate appears to have spotted the Countess.
The tequila is flowing, the women are dancing, and the entire evening has the atmosphere of a vacation that will eventually require a group debriefing.
The pirate performance continues, and the women are thoroughly enjoying themselves. There is something particularly delightful about watching a group of extremely wealthy Manhattan women enthusiastically participate in a nightclub pirate spectacle. These are people who spend their days discussing real estate, social standing, and the proper etiquette for attending charity functions. Tonight, they are shaking their pirate booties in St. Barth’s.
But the real entertainment is happening around LuAnn.
Remember Jacques? The French boyfriend? The man with whom LuAnn has an established relationship? Well, he is presumably somewhere else, blissfully unaware that his girlfriend is enjoying an evening with a man whose occupational description appears to involve dressing like a fictional pirate and looking devastatingly like Johnny Depp.
The evening continues, and eventually the women return to the villa.
Or, more accurately, most of the women return to the villa and settle in for the night.
LuAnn, however, apparently has other plans.
The next morning, the atmosphere has shifted from vacation euphoria to investigative journalism. There are whispers about what happened after the ladies went home, and the central question is whether LuAnn continued her evening with Tomas.
This is where the Countess’s carefully cultivated composure becomes particularly entertaining.
The women begin discussing the previous night’s activities, and the possibility that LuAnn brought the pirate back to the villa becomes a topic of considerable interest.
Now, let’s appreciate the circumstances here. These women have been on the island for approximately five minutes. They have barely unpacked their luggage. They have not yet established a routine, identified the best beach, or determined which restaurant serves the most acceptable lunch.
And already there is a potential sexual scandal.
The St. Barth’s vacation is off to an extraordinarily productive start.
LuAnn’s explanation involves running into old Italian friends, which is an interesting development given that the person everyone is discussing is a French-speaking pirate named Tomas.
The geography of this explanation is perhaps less important than the fact that nobody seems particularly convinced.
Ramona, Heather, and Carole are among those interested in determining exactly what happened. They have questions. They have suspicions. They have the sort of investigative enthusiasm usually reserved for a missing persons case or a particularly juicy episode of Dateline.
And LuAnn, who presumably thought she was going to enjoy a relaxing tropical vacation, is now facing a full-scale inquiry into her overnight activities.
There is also the small matter of her relationship with Jacques. LuAnn is not single, and the women are well aware of that fact. This is not simply a question of whether someone brought a handsome stranger back to the villa. It is a question of whether the Countess has been conducting herself in a manner consistent with the romantic commitments she has been publicly maintaining.
And, frankly, the pirate is not exactly helping her case.
The episode closes with the tantalizing beginnings of what will become one of the most memorable Housewives vacation scandals ever filmed.
We have a luxury villa, a group of women who cannot resist investigating one another’s private lives, a French-speaking pirate, and a Countess whose explanation for the previous evening is not exactly putting the matter to rest.
Aviva, meanwhile, is still back in New York, having missed the entire opening act because she couldn’t get on the plane. Somewhere, she is probably relieved. She has avoided the flight, the tequila, the pirate, and the inevitable conversation about everyone’s sexual history.
For once, the woman with the prosthetic leg is not the person making the biggest scene.
And that, dear readers, is how we arrive at the beginning of the St. Barth’s pirate saga.
The Countess has encountered her Jack Sparrow, the women have smelled blood in the water, and the island is about to become considerably less relaxing.
To be continued. Because this particular pirate has not yet finished plundering the social lives of Manhattan’s finest.


Leave a Reply