
Key West is supposed to be a vacation destination, a place where people go to drink, relax, enjoy the sunshine, and temporarily forget that they have enormous problems waiting for them back home. I love Key West, even though the last time I went it was absolutely freezing. The shrimpries are excellent. Unfortunately, the women of Miami have brought their problems with them, and Lisa Hochstein’s marriage is currently being held together with approximately three strands of dental floss and a prayer.
We begin with Lisa’s increasingly difficult situation with Lenny. The women have been noticing that something is wrong, and Lisa is finally opening up about just how bad things have become. Lenny has apparently decided that marriage is an optional arrangement, and that a younger woman is a perfectly acceptable substitute for communicating with the wife who lives in his house and raises his children.
Lisa explains that Lenny has been leaving her for another woman, and the situation is considerably more humiliating and painful than the usual Housewives marital disagreement. This isn’t an argument over who spent too much money or whose name was left off a guest list. Lisa is describing the disintegration of her marriage while trying to process the fact that her husband seems to have already moved on.
The women listen, and their reactions make it clear that they are not particularly impressed with Lenny’s behavior. There is something especially galling about a man who has enjoyed the benefits of a marriage, a family, and a beautiful home suddenly behaving as though his wife is an inconvenient piece of furniture that needs to be moved out of the way.
Lisa is struggling to reconcile the husband she thought she had with the man who is now treating her this way. She has spent years building a life with Lenny, and now she is being forced to contemplate the possibility that the life she thought was secure was not nearly as secure as she imagined.
Meanwhile, the other women are attempting to enjoy Key West, although the concept of a peaceful Housewives vacation is about as realistic as Lenny suddenly developing an interest in marital counseling.
Alexia is celebrating her birthday, which should be a relatively uncomplicated affair. There is cake, there is attention, and there is the opportunity for everyone to acknowledge that Alexia is another year older and presumably another year more experienced at turning a minor disagreement into an international incident.
Julia, however, becomes the target of Alexia’s commentary. Alexia makes insulting remarks about Julia and her birthplace, taking the conversation into decidedly uncomfortable territory. The remarks about Russian women and their supposed association with prostitution are particularly offensive. Julia is understandably unhappy about being reduced to a stereotype based on where she comes from.
It is an extraordinary choice of conversation for a birthday celebration. Alexia has managed to take an occasion that should be about celebrating herself and turn it into an opportunity to insult someone else’s background. Apparently, the birthday candles weren’t providing quite enough heat, so she decided to manufacture some.
Julia is not particularly interested in accepting the implication that her birthplace somehow determines her character. And why should she? She is a woman who has built a life, a marriage, and a family, and she does not need Alexia explaining the moral character of an entire population to her.
Alexia’s comments are especially frustrating because she doesn’t seem to appreciate why Julia is offended. Instead of recognizing that she has crossed a line, she gets caught up in defending herself and the conversation becomes another exercise in Alexia’s increasingly familiar approach to conflict: say something insulting, discover that someone is offended, and then spend the remainder of the interaction explaining why the offended person is the one creating the problem.
This is becoming something of a specialty.
Back at the center of the episode, however, Lisa’s situation takes an even more upsetting turn. While she is away in Key West, she becomes increasingly concerned about what is happening at home. Specifically, she fears that Lenny is bringing his new girlfriend into the house while their children are there.
Let that sink in for a moment.
Lisa is away with the women, trying to process the fact that her marriage is falling apart, and now she is worried that the woman her husband is involved with may be entering the family home while her children are present.
This is not simply a question of whether Lenny is seeing someone else. It is the possibility that he is introducing that relationship into the children’s lives while Lisa is still trying to understand what is happening to her own family.
Lisa becomes increasingly distressed and starts making phone calls to figure out what is going on. Her calls to the people at home demonstrate just how desperate she is for information. She is trying to establish whether the girlfriend is there, whether the children are around, and whether Lenny is actually doing what she fears he is doing.
At one point, Lisa is so concerned that she wants the nanny to go in and catch Lenny with the girlfriend. It is an extraordinary situation, and the fact that Lisa feels she needs to arrange surveillance of her own marital home while she is on vacation tells us just how far things have deteriorated.
There is something particularly heartbreaking about watching her try to manage this from a distance. She cannot simply walk into the house and see what is happening. She has to rely on other people to tell her what is going on in the place where she lives with her husband and children.
The emotional whiplash is considerable. One minute she is supposed to be enjoying a trip with her friends, and the next she is trying to coordinate an investigation into her husband’s activities.
And Lenny, for his part, appears to have very little appreciation for the humiliation and distress this is causing his wife.
The women are understandably concerned about Lisa. Whatever their individual disagreements might be, they can recognize that this is a genuinely painful situation. Lisa isn’t dealing with a petty argument or a temporary marital cold spell. She is confronting the possibility that the person she built her family with has decided that he would rather be somewhere else, with someone else, while she is left to deal with the consequences.
The contrast between the two major storylines is rather remarkable. Alexia is busy arguing about Julia’s birthplace, while Lisa is trying to determine whether her husband’s girlfriend is inside her house with her children. One woman is having a birthday argument. The other is experiencing a marital crisis that would make most people want to cancel every social engagement on their calendar for the foreseeable future.
And yet, this is Miami, where no emotional crisis is complete without another woman finding an opportunity to make the conversation about herself.
The episode’s title, Dumped and Dumbfounded, is particularly appropriate for Lisa. She is trying to understand how her marriage reached this point, why Lenny is behaving this way, and what she is supposed to do next. She is also trying to protect her children from the fallout, which makes the entire situation even more complicated.
There is no neat resolution here. Lisa is still trying to get answers, and the women are still processing what she has told them. The Key West trip has become less of a vacation and more of an extended group therapy session, except the therapist is missing, the patients are wearing designer resort clothing, and somebody is inevitably going to insult somebody else’s country of origin before the session ends.
The most disturbing part of Lisa’s situation is the degree to which she has been put in the position of having to investigate her own marriage. She should not have to send someone into her house to determine whether her husband is entertaining another woman while their children are there. She should not have to spend a birthday trip monitoring phone calls and trying to establish what is happening in her own home.
And while the women of Miami are certainly not strangers to messy relationships, Lenny’s apparent disregard for the emotional consequences of his behavior is particularly unpleasant to watch.
As for Alexia, she has managed to make Julia’s birthplace a birthday-party talking point, which is quite an accomplishment considering the competition for attention in this group.
Key West has delivered sunshine, birthday celebrations, international insults, marital devastation, and a woman attempting to conduct a domestic investigation from a hotel room.
In other words, a perfectly ordinary vacation for the Real Housewives of Miami.
Next time, the women return to Miami, where Lisa and Larsa will have an opportunity to confront Lenny and his girlfriend at the Formula 1 event. Because apparently the only thing better than discovering your husband’s new girlfriend is to discover her in public, at a major sporting event, with cameras rolling.
Miami, as always, has no intention of letting anyone have a quiet week.


Leave a Reply