RHOC, Season 20, Episode 4–Boxed In

The Orange County dinosaur enclosure is four episodes into its twentieth season, and apparently the biggest emergency facing these prehistoric socialites is a TikTok exclusion crisis. Somewhere, a meteor is hurtling toward Earth, but Tamra Judge is busy wondering why Heather Dubrow won’t post her in a video. Priorities, ladies.

We begin with Gina, Emily, and Shannon making TikToks, because nothing says a productive afternoon like three grown women trying to become fluent in an app designed for teenagers. The conversation inevitably circles back to Carmella’s birthday gift to Emily: a Dior clutch containing a vibrator. Emily insists she thought it was funny, which is probably the correct response when someone hands you a luxury handbag with a surprise sex toy tucked inside. Gina, however, is doing the math. A Dior bag worth more than $3,000 from someone Emily barely knows? Is Carmella buying friendship, making an impression, or simply operating on a different financial planet? Gina wonders aloud whether Carmella is trying to buy Emily’s love. And just like that, a perfectly ridiculous gag gift becomes a full-blown financial investigation.

Meanwhile, Tamra takes Jenn and Heather to visit Fernanda Rocha, an old friend from the show’s fossil record and Tamra’s self-proclaimed hall pass. Fernanda is teaching a Brazilian booty workout, which gives the ladies an opportunity to sweat, stretch, and apparently discuss their friendship problems in athletic wear. Jenn opens up about her difficult conversation with her son Greyson, who has been struggling with the effects of his parents’ divorce. It’s a genuinely vulnerable moment, and Jenn is clearly carrying a lot of guilt about not realizing how much he was hurting. Heather and Tamra offer their thoughts, but the conversation soon takes the familiar Orange County exit ramp straight into Heather’s alleged friendship crimes.

Tamra announces that Heather keeps leaving her out of TikToks. Not just once, mind you. There was apparently a TikTok filmed at BravoCon that never made it onto Heather’s account. The horror. Tamra feels Heather is happy to be friends privately but doesn’t want anyone to know about it publicly. Heather, who seems genuinely confused that her social media posting schedule has become a referendum on her character, maintains that she’s been a loyal friend. Jenn isn’t entirely convinced, and suddenly the workout has turned into a group therapy session with better leggings.

Vicki, meanwhile, spends time with her son Michael, who is now forty and working remotely for Coto Insurance from Spain. The show treats us to a flashback of little Michael describing his mother as constantly stressed, which is both nostalgic and an excellent reminder that Vicki has been Vicki for approximately two geological eras. Now she is asking whether he plans to have children and whether he should freeze his sperm. Nothing says a relaxing lunch with your mother quite like a reproductive planning consultation. Michael seems perfectly content with his life as it is, while Vicki reflects on how her divorce from Donn fractured the family. She admits that it’s one of her biggest regrets. There’s a little more heart in this conversation than the usual OC bickering, and it’s a reminder that twenty years of television means we’ve watched these kids grow up alongside their mothers’ increasingly elaborate hair.

Carmella’s gift is still making the rounds, and she finally gets to explain herself. At dinner with Tamra and Jenn, she is understandably irritated that Gina has questioned her motives and her finances. She doesn’t appreciate being interrogated about how much she spends, especially after Shannon apparently shared that Carmella pays $35,000 a month in rent. Thirty-five thousand dollars. That is not rent; that is a small municipality’s annual housing budget. Carmella explains that she’s a real estate agent and broker with a focus on development, and says she’s sold nearly $100 million in the last decade. She also shares that after discovering her husband had allegedly cheated, she got her real estate license and sold the house they were building, making more than a million dollars in the process. She’s clearly proud of what she’s accomplished, and she doesn’t want Gina treating her like some mysterious rich lady who wandered onto the set with a credit card and a suspiciously large handbag. Fair enough. But this is Housewives, Carmella. If you show up with a $3,000 gift and a vibrator, people are going to ask questions. It’s practically in the franchise bylaws.

Vicki also gets a whale-watching outing on the calendar, partly to get the women together and partly because she is still concerned about the situation in Puerto Vallarta. The ladies head out on the water, where Heather demonstrates that even casual whale watching requires an appropriate designer wardrobe. Naturally. Vicki takes another opportunity to make comments about Carmella’s past, because apparently the woman cannot simply exist without being assessed by the Orange County fossil council.

Then comes Tamra’s taco party, which is intended to cheer everyone up amid the concerns about violence in Mexico. Shannon arrives carrying an enormous box of decorations, nearly toppling over in the process. The party has tacos, decorations, and a game Tamra has devised called “Friend in a Box.” Because if there’s one thing this group needs, it’s another opportunity to anonymously criticize one another while pretending it’s a fun activity.

Each woman decorates a box, and the others write anonymous notes about her. It’s basically a middle-school friendship exercise, except the participants have mortgages, cosmetic procedures, and decades of unresolved resentment. Heather receives a note suggesting that Tamra can cut her deeply. Tamra takes the criticism reasonably well, which is almost disappointing given the potential for a dramatic collapse.

But the real explosion comes when Jenn learns that Heather has allegedly described her as obsessed with Tamra. Emily relays the comment, and Jenn is understandably upset. Heather tries to explain that she meant Jenn brings Tamra up frequently whenever they’re together, not that she’s stalking her through the Orange County wilderness with binoculars and a scrapbook. Emily insists Heather used the word obsessed. Jenn points out that Tamra used the same accusation against her last season, so hearing it from Heather feels particularly pointed. Heather says she didn’t mean it that way and eventually apologizes for the wording. The two agree to keep working on their friendship, which is a very diplomatic conclusion to a fight that began with a conversation about how often one woman mentions another woman.

Shannon also receives a note from Tamra calling her kind but someone who holds grudges. Tamra tells her she loves and adores her, and the two revisit their reconciliation. Tamra gets emotional, explaining how much Shannon’s invitation and kindness have meant to her. She apologizes again for the horrible things she’s said, and Shannon seems to believe this apology is genuine. We shall see. In Orange County, friendship is a delicate ecosystem, and one misplaced TikTok can send the entire herd stampeding.

By the end, we’ve investigated a Dior handbag, debated a vibrator, questioned a woman’s professional credentials, revisited a twenty-year-old family dynamic, and held a group exercise in anonymous criticism. All because these dinosaurs apparently cannot spend an afternoon together without opening a box and discovering a new reason to be offended. The boxes are open, the friendships are complicated, and the TikToks remain conspicuously incomplete.

Comments

Leave a Reply